How to choose brand colours

How to choose brand colours

Everyone with a small business has done the same thing: opened Pinterest, collected colours that felt right, picked two, and moved on. A month later the problem shows up. The colour looks good in the logo and nowhere else. Text on a button in that colour is hard to read, and a caption over it disappears.

The reason is not that your taste is bad. It is that you picked a colour for a logo when what you needed was a colour system for a brand. The difference between the two comes down to one published number that almost nobody mentions.

You are not choosing a colour, you are choosing a relationship

A colour on its own means nothing operationally. What means something is a colour against the colour behind it. Whether text can be read is decided by the difference between the text colour and the background, not by how attractive either one is.

So "what is the best brand colour" is the wrong question. The right one is "against which background, and in which place". The same colour can be fine in a logo and unusable on a button.

And a colour goes to far more places than the logo: a button on the site, text over a coloured panel, a story, a printed invoice, a profile picture next to WhatsApp green, and dark mode if you have it. Choosing on the basis of the logo means choosing for one place out of six.

What this covers
What this covers

The number that is not an opinion

There is an international standard for the web called WCAG, published by the W3C, and one of its criteria is Contrast (Minimum), numbered 1.4.3 at Level AA. It says something specific: normal text must have a contrast ratio against its background of "at least 4.5:1".

For large text the requirement drops to "3:1". Large is defined precisely, as at least 18 point, or 14 point when bold, which the page notes is roughly equivalent to 24px and 18.5px.

One practical detail matters more than it sounds. These are thresholds, not targets to round towards. The page states that computed values are not rounded, so 4.499:1 does not meet the 4.5:1 requirement. If a tool tells you 4.4, you have not nearly passed. You have failed.

The paradox: your logo is exempt, your site is not

This is the part that explains everything, and it rarely gets said. The same page lists explicit exceptions, and the first one is this: "Text that is part of a logo or brand name has no contrast requirement."

So if you chose two colours and they looked right in the logo, that is not evidence of anything. The logo is exempt from the rule in writing. The website, the buttons and the body text are not. That is why a colour "works" in the logo and fails everywhere else. Nothing went wrong in your judgement. You tested it in the one place where the rule does not apply.

The practical consequence: start from the button and the body text, not from the logo. A colour that passes on a button will work in a logo automatically. The reverse does not hold.

At a glance
At a glance

Buttons have a second number

There is another criterion in the same standard, Non-text Contrast, numbered 1.4.11, also Level AA. It covers things that are not text: user interface components and graphics needed to understand the content. The requirement there is "a contrast ratio of at least 3:1 against adjacent color(s)".

So the button itself, its edge and its shape, has to be distinguishable from the page at 3:1, regardless of the text inside it. There are exceptions for inactive components and for anything whose appearance comes from the browser and was not modified by the author.

That means a single button carries two separate requirements, not one: the text inside it needs 4.5:1 against the button, and the button needs 3:1 against the page. This is what rules out the pleasant pale colour as a primary action colour.

The order that works

  • 1. Start with the core pair: text colour and background colour. That is ninety per cent of the page. Pick a very light or very dark background and a dark grey or off-white type colour. Measure it. It has to clear 4.5.
  • 2. Then the action colour: one colour for buttons and links. Measure it twice, against the page at 3:1 and against any text that will sit on it at 4.5:1.
  • 3. Then the logo: take it from the two above. The logo is exempt, so it is the easiest case you have, not the hardest.
  • 4. Test in the real places: a printed invoice in black and white, a small profile picture, a story, and a phone screen in sunlight.
  • 5. Allow yourself one more colour only: something for warnings and errors. More than that is not a system, it is a collection.

The time saver is this: pick two colours and a background, then stop. Most of the brands you find coherent use one colour seriously and grey for everything else.

Where colours actually fail

A mood board shows a colour at its best, as a large block next to another large block. Reality is different:

  • White text on a mid-tone button. The most common failure. The fix is either a darker button or darker text.
  • Light grey on white. It looks tidy and misses the threshold by a wide margin.
  • Placeholder text in forms. Usually left pale, and it is text that has to be read.
  • The colour in print. A screen colour is not a printed colour, and an invoice or a card will show you the gap.
  • Dark mode. The same colour turns harsh against dark and needs a second version.

Honest limits

First, this standard is about accessibility, not taste. Clearing 4.5:1 does not make a brand good. It means people can read it. Taste is a separate thing with no number attached, and I am not going to invent one.

Second, you can break it deliberately. The logo exemption is written into the standard, so keeping a low-contrast logo you are attached to is a legitimate decision. Carrying that same logic into the website is not.

Third, most of what you read about colour psychology is not science. "Blue signals trust" and "red increases appetite" get repeated without a source, and I will not build a decision on them. What I have evidence for is the contrast numbers above, and they solve most of the problem on their own.

And fourth, if you have no site or product yet, this is premature. Pick two colours and move. People who spent a month on colours delayed the business by a month and changed the colours afterwards anyway. The same logic runs through why you should not rebrand before answering these questions.

Colour is a small part of a visual identity, and a full identity guide covers type, spacing and logo usage too. The KF Agency team wrote a practical breakdown of what belongs in a visual identity guide, in Arabic, and it is the right place to continue once the two colours are settled.

If you are still treating the brand as the logo, the sequence starts at a brand is not just a logo, and on logo size specifically there is making the logo bigger does not matter. If the colours are settled and the words are missing, how to write a brand story is the next step.

A channel is a place; a strategy is a reason. The channel tells you where you will show up, the strategy tells you why anyone will listen. That difference is what lets a growth system run on more than one road instead of leaning on a single funnel, and I wrote it out in Part 3, Strategies: where will you win of Growth Engine, a free book in Arabic.

Want to grow your business?

Book a free consultation and we will look at what is blocking growth and what to do next.

Book a free consultation
← Strategy and brand